The Role of the Attorney General in the Cayman Islands

The Attorney General (AG) is one of the most important legal officers in the Cayman Islands government. As the chief legal adviser to the government, head of the public prosecutions function, and a member of the Legislature, the AG plays a unique role that bridges law, government, and the public interest.

Here is what you need to know about this office.

The Constitutional Basis

The Attorney General's role is addressed in Section 55 of the Cayman Islands Constitution, which deals with the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP). In the Cayman Islands, the Attorney General and Director of Public Prosecutions functions are combined in a single office.

The AG is:

• The principal legal adviser to the government of the Cayman Islands
• The head of the Attorney General's Chambers (the government's legal department)
• Responsible for public prosecutions — deciding whether criminal charges are brought
• An ex officio (by virtue of their office) member of the Legislative Assembly, meaning they sit in Parliament but without a vote on most matters

Appointment of the Attorney General

The AG is appointed by the Governor, acting after consultation with the Premier. The position is a senior Crown appointment — not an elected one.

Because the AG is appointed rather than elected, they are intended to be independent from immediate political pressures in exercising their prosecutorial functions. The person appointed is typically a senior lawyer with extensive experience in public law and criminal prosecution.

Role 1: Government's Chief Legal Adviser

The AG's Chambers advise the government on:

• Constitutional matters: Whether proposed legislation is consistent with the Constitution; legal implications of constitutional questions
• Legislative drafting: Working with Parliamentary Counsel to ensure bills are legally sound
• Government contracts and transactions: Legal advice on major financial and commercial dealings
• International obligations: Legal advice on treaties, international law, and the Cayman Islands' obligations as a British Overseas Territory
• Litigation: Representing the government in court when the Crown is a party

This advisory role is crucial. A government that consistently acts on sound legal advice is less likely to have its decisions challenged or overturned in court.

Role 2: Prosecution of Criminal Offences

One of the AG's most significant functions is oversight of criminal prosecutions. The Attorney General or a designated prosecutor decides whether to bring or continue criminal charges.

The prosecution process works like this:

1. Police investigation: The Royal Cayman Islands Police Service investigates alleged offences and gathers evidence
2. File submitted to AG's Chambers: Police submit a file recommending charges
3. Charging decision: Prosecutors in the AG's Chambers review the evidence and apply the "Full Code Test":
   • Is there sufficient evidence that a conviction is more likely than not?
   • Is it in the public interest to prosecute?
4. Charges brought or dropped: If both tests are met, charges are filed. If not, the case may be dropped or diverted.

This function is quasi-judicial — the AG must exercise independent judgement, free from political interference.

The Independence of Prosecution Decisions

Section 55 of the Constitution specifically addresses the independence of prosecution decisions. It states that in the exercise of prosecutorial functions, the AG must act independently of political direction.

This is critically important. If political figures could direct the AG to prosecute their enemies or protect their allies, the rule of law would collapse. The constitutional protection of prosecutorial independence is what keeps the criminal justice system from becoming a tool of political power.

In practice:

• Ministers cannot instruct the AG to charge or not charge specific individuals
• The AG can consult ministers on policy questions relating to prosecution (such as prosecution policy for minor drug offences), but individual case decisions are the AG's alone
• The AG must give reasons if declining to prosecute in cases of public interest

The AG's Membership of the Legislative Assembly

The AG sits in the Legislative Assembly as an ex officio member — meaning they attend by virtue of their office, not by election. This allows the AG to:

• Introduce government bills on behalf of the Cabinet
• Provide legal explanations to members
• Answer legal questions in the Assembly
• Participate in debates on legislation

However, the AG does not have the right to vote in the Assembly on most matters and is not counted in the votes of confidence that determine the government's survival. This reflects the AG's role as a legal officer rather than an elected politician.

The Attorney General's Chambers

The AG leads the Attorney General's Chambers — the government's in-house legal department. The Chambers comprises:

• Senior prosecutors who handle serious criminal cases
• Legal advisers who advise government departments
• Civil litigation lawyers who represent the government in court
• Specialist lawyers handling financial crimes, corporate law, and other areas

The quality of the AG's Chambers significantly affects the quality of governance. Good legal advice prevents government mistakes; effective prosecution upholds the rule of law.

The AG and the Human Rights Commission

The Human Rights Commission (established under Section 116) can make recommendations about legal reforms and investigate complaints. The AG's Chambers plays a role in implementing legal changes recommended by the Commission, and the AG may be consulted on the legal implications of human rights concerns.

A Hypothetical: A High-Profile Prosecution Decision

Imagine that police investigate a prominent politician for alleged financial corruption. The file is submitted to the AG's Chambers. The evidence is substantial but circumstantial — not certain to secure a conviction.

What happens?

1. Senior prosecutors review the evidence applying the Full Code Test
2. They assess: is there sufficient evidence, and is prosecution in the public interest?
3. If both tests are met, charges are filed regardless of the politician's prominence
4. If the evidence is insufficient, no charges are brought — regardless of public pressure to "do something"
5. The AG cannot be directed by the Premier or Cabinet in this decision

If the public or media believes the decision was improper — whether a failure to charge or an improper prosecution — they can raise the matter through parliamentary scrutiny, the media, or ultimately judicial review.

The AG and International Mutual Legal Assistance

The Cayman Islands, as a major financial centre, is regularly involved in international cooperation on criminal investigations. The AG's Chambers plays a central role in:

• Processing mutual legal assistance (MLA) requests from foreign governments seeking evidence in Cayman
• Ensuring requests comply with Cayman law and constitutional requirements
• Pursuing financial crime that crosses international borders

This is a significant part of the AG's work — balancing Cayman's role as a cooperative partner in international law enforcement with the protection of due process rights for those under investigation.

How the AG's Role Differs from a Private Lawyer

A private lawyer's primary duty is to their client. The AG's primary duty is to the public interest and to the rule of law — not just to the government of the day. This means:

• The AG can advise the government that proposed legislation is unlawful and should not proceed
• The AG can decline to pursue a prosecution that is not in the public interest
• The AG must disclose relevant evidence to defence lawyers even if it helps the accused
• The AG has ethical duties as a lawyer that cannot be overridden by political instruction

FAQ: The Attorney General in the Cayman Islands

Can the AG prosecute the Premier? Yes. The AG's prosecutorial independence means they can initiate charges against any person, including senior politicians, if the evidence and public interest tests are met.

Can I make a complaint about a prosecution decision? There is no general right of appeal against a decision not to prosecute. However, decisions can be challenged by judicial review if they were made unlawfully or with procedural impropriety.

Is the AG the same as a court judge? No. Judges are independent members of the judiciary. The AG is a government officer in the executive branch.

Can the AG give legal advice to private citizens? No. The AG's Chambers advises the government, not private individuals. Private citizens need private lawyers.

What happens if the AG has a conflict of interest? The AG would recuse themselves (step aside) from any matter in which they have a personal interest. Another senior lawyer would handle the matter.

Conclusion

The Attorney General of the Cayman Islands occupies a pivotal position at the intersection of law, government, and public interest. As the government's chief legal adviser and head of public prosecutions, the AG's independence and integrity are fundamental to the rule of law.

The constitutional protections for prosecutorial independence are not just formalities — they are the guarantee that the criminal justice system cannot be weaponised for political purposes.

---

Related articles: What Does the Premier of the Cayman Islands Actually Do? | What Is the Constitutional Commission and What Does It Do? | How the Cayman Islands Government Works